Who Should Redesign?

Who Should Redesign?

Who Should Redesign is a fairly new site. Each time you land on the page, vote, skip and entry, or refresh the page a new site shows up. You can cast your vote multiple times relatively quickly. It works quickly. The Who Should Redesign site design is good. I think if it submitted itself for review it would do well.

Quick Voting

The site is responsive. After you vote it keeps a running record down toward the footer. The statistics show up on this thumbnail view of your votes.

Should Not Redesign

There is a Should Redesign page, which the sites voted most for needing a redesign filter to the top. They also have a Should Not Redesign (Meaning it's a good design). It's cool to see the Eden site design as second only to Apple on this site.

Conclusion

The big pitfall I found on the site is I hit the yes button because I liked a design. The idea of hitting yes when it's bad, and hitting no when the design is good is counterintuitive. That's something to consider. Though the site is cool. Let me know if you've used it, or if there are other similar sites out there you've seen, as I'd like to check out others as well.

I submitted AiBURN to the list for the fun of it. I really want to redesign this site when I get a chance, so we'll see what people say. I'm thinking a kind of burnt wood gradient grunge style design.